Rocking the Boat

The media sure is doing a lot of hand-wringing over the Rolling Stone McChrystal profile.  Oh no, you wrote things that were true but allegedly uncleared by your betters! How dare you! I’m telling daddy!

On Friday, however, officials close to McChrystal began trying to salvage his reputation by asserting that the author, Michael Hastings, quoted the general and his staff in conversations that he was allowed to witness but not report. The officials also challenged a statement by Rolling Stone’s executive editor that the magazine had thoroughly reviewed the story with McChrystal’s staff ahead of publication.

The executive editor, Eric Bates, denied that Hastings violated any ground rules when he wrote about the four weeks he spent, on and off, with McChrystal and his team. “A lot of things were said off the record that we didn’t use,” Bates said in an interview. “We abided by all the ground rules in every instance.”

A senior military official insisted that “many of the sessions were off-the-record and intended to give [Hastings] a sense” of how the team operated. The command’s own review of events, said the official, who was unwilling to speak on the record, found “no evidence to suggest” that any of the “salacious political quotes” in the article were made in situations in which ground rules permitted Hastings to use the material in his story.

via Gen. McChrystal allies, Rolling Stone disagree over article’s ground rules.

Jon Stewart described this as the moment the media realized they “kind of suck.”  I don’t know if McChrystal’s just trying to save face or what, but if RS went with this without getting permission then good for them.

1 comment
  1. slimove said:

    i can’t remember where, but i read something somewhere about the journo fact checking the material with mcchrystal before publication. didn’t let him see the article, but did at least run the quotes by him (i think, i’m doing all of this from memory).

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s